Announcement

Collapse

You can find details about the Wildcat Nation Tailgate in the football forum. We hope to see you there!

Class of 2018 - General Discussion

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • UK8STL11
    Senior Member
    • May 2017
    • 696

    #526
    Originally posted by KCKUKFan
    I know that you can't say anything without putting a negative, pessimistic spin on it, crazzed, but Kentucky (and Cal) will be just fine, Zion or no Zion.
    Fine is nice and all, but I’d prefer to compete for national titles.

    And right now (and next year without Zion) that’s not happening.

    Comment

    • teamchemistry15
      Senior Member
      • Oct 2014
      • 7022

      #527
      Originally posted by UK8STL11

      I didn't say they all were locks first off. Secondly, they were all guys Cal went at hard and missed on. Third, if you don't recall Zimmerman, Newman, and Bamba being considered locks to UK then I am not sure what to tell you.

      According to your list Cal missed on nobody that was a UK lean I guess???
      Regarding your third point, he clearly stated those guys were the ones he would throw into that bin. Meaning those are the guys who were once considered locks that went elsewhere. No need in being a jerk while also being wrong.

      Newnan had all sorts of rumors and issues after. Maybe we "missed" on him like we did Shabazz, Ayton, Xavier Henry, and all of those other guys who were trouble. Bol is a bad example. There was some weird stuff going on there after he was cut from the USA team. Bamba I will give you, but even then there's some rumors of him being involved with an agent.

      Comment

      • teamchemistry15
        Senior Member
        • Oct 2014
        • 7022

        #528
        Originally posted by UK8STL11

        Fine is nice and all, but I’d prefer to compete for national titles.

        And right now (and next year without Zion) that’s not happening.
        How do you know that?

        Comment

        • Joneslab
          Senior Member
          • Oct 2014
          • 39604

          #529
          The margin for error definitely shrinks without Zion but there's no reason Kentucky shouldn't be right there for a title next season. It would take a weird turn of events for them to just not be a player. Next year's team is going to be really exciting--and different for the Cal era.

          Regarding "locks" and "leans"--none of us really knows whether a player was a lean or not without being inside the recruitment. But you could make a list of probably 50 players in the Cal era like crazzed did and make a case that something's wrong because we missed on those guys. That's a completely arbitrary exercise.

          Mo Bomba is a great example. It looked like that was a horse race all the way through. Well, information came out later that Texas was in on that so tightly that nobody could have gotten him out of there.

          These kids play the game. In some cases it's up in the air but in most cases the deal is done pretty early. We know this from their comments after the fact. I mean crazzed added Jaylen Brown of all people to that list. I've seen people say that Brown was so notoriously tight-lipped that some people around him thought he might not play in college. How would anybody tell one way or another that that guy was a lean anywhere?

          Comment

          • George
            Senior Member
            • Oct 2014
            • 10355

            #530
            And with regard to Brown, we weren’t in the conversation at all until the absolute last second, then all of a sudden he’s supposedly at prom and preparing to commit to UK. You’ll never make me believe we were seriously in on that kid.

            Comment

            • KCKUKFan
              Senior Member
              • Nov 2014
              • 14228

              #531
              Originally posted by UK8STL11

              Fine is nice and all, but I’d prefer to compete for national titles.

              And right now (and next year without Zion) that’s not happening.
              We were a buzzer beater away from the Final Four last year, and you have no idea what the end of this year is going to bring.

              It's not like we've fallen into some black hole of talentless crap. I think you need to go watch some game film of the end of the Tubby years, or even better, the Billy Clyde experiment. Then take a deep breath, come back here, and re-evaluate.

              By "fine," I meant we'll be in the conversation for the title every year as long as Cal is here. And it's not like he's dumb; he knows he's missed out on a couple of these top five kids. He will adjust accordingly. And even if he doesn't, he'll still bring in second tier five star kids, and we've seen repeatedly how that format wins titles the same as the one-and-done model.
              Last edited by KCKUKFan; 01-05-2018, 04:27 AM.

              Comment

              • KCKUKFan
                Senior Member
                • Nov 2014
                • 14228

                #532
                Originally posted by Will Lavender

                These kids play the game. In some cases it's up in the air but in most cases the deal is done pretty early. We know this from their comments after the fact.
                Which is why I'll believe Zion Williamson goes to Clemson when I see it.

                Remember when Julius Randle was going to Florida? Or Kevin Knox was staying in Carolina? Or Jamal Murray was a lock to Oregon? Or Nerlens Noel was a lock to Georgetown? After the fact they all made it clear that they were never going anywhere other than Kentucky. And that holds true for most of the guys Cal locked in on from an early date.

                When Cal has been 100% zoned in on Zion as a priority for the majority of his recruitment, I see no reason to believe that he's just going to switch up to Clemson of all schools in the last month. Weirder things certainly have happened, and I'm not going to act as if Cal's recruiting hasn't gone from otherworldly to just really good in the past year or two, but if Zion Williamson ends up anywhere other than Kentucky, I'll be surprised.

                Comment

                • BobS
                  Senior Member
                  • Nov 2014
                  • 1291

                  #533
                  If everyone returns that logically should, we could be really good. But returning players at UK under Cal sometimes defies logic.

                  Vanderbilt, SGA and Richards may well be his most important recruits for next year, imo.

                  But if Wiseman reclassifies and joins up, then all bets are off. Nobody would care where ZW went.

                  Comment

                  • Joneslab
                    Senior Member
                    • Oct 2014
                    • 39604

                    #534
                    Originally posted by KCKUKFan
                    It's not like we've fallen into some black hole of talentless crap.
                    Yeah. The hyperbole is a tad over the top, lol.

                    You'd think Cal were sending one-armed blind kids out on the court.

                    Comment

                    • Dwight Schrute
                      Senior Member
                      • Oct 2014
                      • 18716

                      #535
                      Originally posted by Will Lavender

                      Yeah. The hyperbole is a tad over the top, lol.

                      You'd think Cal were sending one-armed blind kids out on the court.
                      Nobody said that. But when your philosophy relies on getting new freshmen phenoms every year, you gotta have a difference maker or it falls apart.

                      Comment

                      • Joneslab
                        Senior Member
                        • Oct 2014
                        • 39604

                        #536
                        Originally posted by Dwight Schrute

                        Nobody said that. But when your philosophy relies on getting new freshmen phenoms every year, you gotta have a difference maker or it falls apart.
                        It looks like the philosophy isn't getting new freshmen phenoms every year all of a sudden.

                        If you don't have phenoms then you can't shuffle the roster. Cal is well aware of that. The trouble comes in when one of those guys who wasn't a phenom starts to turn into one. See Shai.

                        That's when you get holes blown in your program. If you know exactly who's leaving, it's easier to go into a living room and tell a kid they're going to come right in and fill in that spot. If very few are leaving things get sticky on the recruiting trail but they can get better on the actual court of play. See, again, North Carolina. They haven't gotten those phenoms and all they've done is compete for titles.

                        Comment

                        • George
                          Senior Member
                          • Oct 2014
                          • 10355

                          #537
                          Originally posted by Will Lavender
                          If you don't have phenoms then you can't shuffle the roster. Cal is well aware of that. The trouble comes in when one of those guys who wasn't a phenom starts to turn into one. See Shai.
                          The kid isn't a phenom. He's a really good player with a great build for the game, and he's putting up good numbers as of late.

                          If we're calling Shai a phenom, then what in the world was John Wall? Anthony Davis?

                          Comment

                          • Joneslab
                            Senior Member
                            • Oct 2014
                            • 39604

                            #538
                            Originally posted by Downes Van Zandt

                            The kid isn't a phenom. He's a really good player with a great build for the game, and he's putting up good numbers as of late.

                            If we're calling Shai a phenom, then what in the world was John Wall? Anthony Davis?
                            I was being a little tongue in cheek. I mean to say that the trouble comes when you get a player who nobody thinks is a one and done who suddenly may be a one and done. When the experts start raving about these kids that's bad, because the echo chambers starts. That's happening with Shai. That tends to happen when you're 6'6" and nobody can stop you off the drive.

                            One of the reasons it's difficult to pull in phenoms is that they know, and Cal knows, and everybody knows, that Kentucky's roster is dicey next year. It could look similar to this year. Really hard to run the system the way Cal has when they can turn on a television and in five minutes see that we have very few one-and-dones. Zion would likely have to fight here, and that could've been a deal-breaker.

                            Comment

                            • Joneslab
                              Senior Member
                              • Oct 2014
                              • 39604

                              #539
                              Sam Vencenie tweeted day before yesterday that Shai could go as high as middle of the first round.

                              Comment

                              • George
                                Senior Member
                                • Oct 2014
                                • 10355

                                #540
                                Originally posted by Will Lavender
                                Sam Vencenie tweeted day before yesterday that Shai could go as high as middle of the first round.
                                I'm so sick of this.

                                Comment

                                 

                                Forum Ch-ch-changes - Report Here

                                Hello All! You may see some things bouncing around, colors changing, and functionality being added and removed as we look at how to make some requested...
                                 

                                A Word From Our Founder

                                With the recent discussion of rules and what is and is not posted I set out to find what our mission statement originally was and this is what I found:...

                                Class of 2018 - General Discussion

                                Collapse
                                Working...