Board Draft

[catfaninin]

I'm good with whatever. I think doing it tournament style might get complicated. Lighthouse's idea of having each of us involved rank the teams, then figure an average would be the simplest. It would be nice if we could have the voting done by people who were not involved but I'm not sure we would get much in the way of feedback.

However the voting is done I would say don't start it until at least Monday. Give everyone the weekend to make the case for their team.

[George]

Yeah, I say we each assign a number 1-10 to each team, then tally it up. Either we each post our rankings in a comment, or we keep it anonymous by sending our rankings through PMs to teamchemistry15 (or whoever' swilling to be responsible). I'm fine with either.

Ties could be settled through brief debates between GMs, while the other GMs declare a winner based on those debates.

[teamchemistry15]

Yeah, I say we each assign a number 1-10 to each team, then tally it up. Either we each post our rankings in a comment, or we keep it anonymous by sending our rankings through PMs to teamchemistry15 (or whoever' swilling to be responsible). I'm fine with either.

Ties could be settled through brief debates between GMs, while the other GMs declare a winner based on those debates.

That sounds good as well. I'm fine with this or the tournament. So, how about we start a new thread where we list our team and a paragraph or so bragging on it. I know we have that already, but I mean a thread that has 11 responses only. One from each team and no side chatter so it's easy for us to look through. Once we all have done that we each rank the other 10 teams 1-10. We do not rank ourself. After everyone is ranked (I think we can open it up to those who didn't participate in the draft as well) we take an average of each team. If there are any ties we can create a thread for that tie and have a vote just of the two teams.

[Lighthouse]

That sounds good as well. I'm fine with this or the tournament. So, how about we start a new thread where we list our team and a paragraph or so bragging on it. I know we have that already, but I mean a thread that has 11 responses only. One from each team and no side chatter so it's easy for us to look through. Once we all have done that we each rank the other 10 teams 1-10. We do not rank ourself. After everyone is ranked (I think we can open it up to those who didn't participate in the draft as well) we take an average of each team. If there are any ties we can create a thread for that tie and have a vote just of the two teams.

I like this idea. I also like someone's idea to start the voting Monday.

[KevinHall]

That sounds good as well. I'm fine with this or the tournament. So, how about we start a new thread where we list our team and a paragraph or so bragging on it. I know we have that already, but I mean a thread that has 11 responses only. One from each team and no side chatter so it's easy for us to look through. Once we all have done that we each rank the other 10 teams 1-10. We do not rank ourself. After everyone is ranked (I think we can open it up to those who didn't participate in the draft as well) we take an average of each team. If there are any ties we can create a thread for that tie and have a vote just of the two teams.

This sounds fine to me.

[J.Jennings]

We're losing him, gang.

You ever seen the movie O Brother Art Thou??? Im like George Nelson, yesterday i was turned up on a high today im on a low lol lol lol lol lol lol lol lol.....